|
Completing a Final Mission for Matt Louis Urban
Primus inter pares
First among equals
Pierwszy pomiędzy równymi
by Anthony J. Bajdek
May1, 2007
Lieutenant Colonel Matt Louis Urban is one of them. Their number will
perpetually remain the same: 434. They were, and a few still are, the
American soldiers, sailors, airmen, and marines who during World War II
earned the U. S. Congressional Medal of Honor, America's highest honor for
members of its Armed Forces, the only decoration given in recognition of
conduct in battle above and beyond the call of duty.
A consideration of their harrowing combat accomplishments, as written in
their Congressional Medal of Honor citations, is a humbling experience for
any reader. I have read their citations. Better than one of every three of
them had been killed in action, with the last being killed in action on
June 8, 1945. The vast majority of them were ordinary Americans living in
extraordinary times. They virtually represented all the enlisted ranks as
well as the ranks of commissioned officers. They represented, from
December 7, 1941, at the start of the War, through July 29, 1945 when the
final Congressional Medal of Honor recipient earned his citation, the
spectrum of American servicemen of different ethnicities and races,
including Captain Audie Murphy who for many years was held to be America's
most-decorated soldier of World War II.
At least nine of those Congressional Medal of Honor recipients had been
Americans of Polish descent. There may be others with mothers of Polish
ancestry, but their numbers are nearly impossible to determine, without
extensive, painstaking research. Therefore, as I begin this article, I
believe it worthwhile and fitting indeed to mention the names of the nine
that we can identify, there origins, and CMH (i.e., Congressional Medal of
Honor)-cited "fields of glory" because in not too many more years they
will not be remembered collectively as the memory of World War II fades
deeper and deeper into history:
- Sergeant Sylvester Antolak, U. S. Army, Company B, 15th Infantry, 3d
Infantry Division, born in St. Clairsville, Ohio, killed in CMH-cited
action on 24 May 1944 near Cisternia di Littoria, Italy.
- Private First Class John Dutko, U. S. Army, 3d Infantry Division, born in
Dilltown, Pennsylvania, killed in CMH-cited action on 23 May 1944 near
Ponte Rotto, Italy.
- Private First Class William J. Grabiarz, U. S. Army, Troop E, 5th Cavalry,
1st Cavalry Division, born in Buffalo, New York, killed in CMH-cited
action on 23 February 1945 in Manila, Luzon, the Philippine Islands.
- Private First Class Anthony L. Krotiak, U. S. Army, Company I, 148th
Infantry, 37th Infantry Division, born in Chicago, Illinois, killed in
CHM- cited action on 8 May 1945 in Balete Pass, Luzon, the Philippine
Islands.
- Private First Class Edward J. Moskala, U. S. Army, Company C, 383d
Infantry, 96th Infantry Division, born in Chicago, Illinois, killed in
CMH-cited action on 9 April 1945 on Kakazu Ridge, Okinawa, Ryukyu Islands.
- Sergeant Joseph J. Sadowski, U. S. Army, 37th Tank Battalion, 4th Armored
Division, born in Perth Amboy, New Jersey, killed in CMH-cited action on
14 September 1944 at Valhey, France.
- Second Lieutenant Joseph R. Sarnoski, U. S. Army Air Corps, 43d Bomber
Group, born in Simpson, Pennsylvania, killed in CMH-cited action on 16
June 1943 over Buka Area, the Solomon Islands.
- Captain Matt Louis Urban, U. S. Army, 2d Battalion, 60th Infantry
Regiment, 9th Infantry Division, born in Buffalo, New York, survived seven
separate CMH-cited combat actions on 14 June, 15 June, 25 July, 2 August,
15 August, and 3 September, 1944 in battles in Renouf, Orglandes, and St.
Lô, France and in Heer, Belgium.
- Private First Class Frank P. Witek, 1st Batallion, 9th Marines, 3d Marine
Division, born in Derby, Connecticut, killed in CMH-cited action on 3
August, 1944 during the Battle of Finegayan at Guam, the Marianas Islands.
This article isn't about whether Matt Urban or Audie Murphy had earned the
greater number of decorations in World War II. According to the Total Army
Personnel Command in Alexandria, Virginia, Matt Urban, along with Audie
Murphy, has the distinction of being the most decorated American combat
soldier of the War. Both Urban and Murphy each received 29 decorations,
including the Congressional Medal of Honor. Consult also the Arlington
National Cemetery website on Matt Urban
(www.arlingtoncemetery.com/murban.htm) which confirms that his
:"exploits on WWII battlefields earned him as many citations as the
legendary Audie Murphy, thereby making him one of America's most-decorated
soldiers."
The flames of that controversy have been fueled by the fact that the 1989
Guinness Book of World Records identified Matt Urban as "The Most
Combat-Decorated Soldier in American History" and in the June 11, 1984
issue of PEOPLE Weekly magazine, staff writer Michael Ryan stated in his
An American Hero article that a "generation of Americans was taught that
Audie Murphy - heroic soldier, Medal of Honor holder, later movie star -
was the most decorated U. S. fighting man of World War II. That was true -
until 1980, when former Lieutenant Colonel Matt Urban received a spate of
honors - including his seventh Purple Heart, a Croix de Guerre, the Legion
of Merit and the Congressional Medal of Honor - all of which had been lost
in a bureaucratic shuffle at the end of the War. With 29 medals in 20
months, Urban is the most decorated soldier in U. S. history."
We supporters of Urban must be careful not to denigrate Captain Audie
Murphy's outstanding CMH-cited exemplary heroism in one battle near
Holtzwihr, France on January 26, 1945 in which he was wounded once.
Neither should they decry the fact that the United States Postal Service
issued, in the year 2000, a commemorative stamp that honored Audie Murphy
as well as three other American combat heroes of World Wars I and II.
After all, Postal Service regulations require a ten-year period following
the death of a potential honoree before issuing a commemorative stamp.
Audie Murphy died in 1971. Matt Urban died in 1995, thereby making him
eligible for a commemorative stamp in 2005.
Urban's story is truly remarkable even by standards established for the
Congressional Medal of Honor in that he received the Congressional Medal
of Honor not only because in exceeding the typical one or two displays of
battlefield courage above and beyond the call of duty but also because, as
stated in his Congressional Medal of Honor citation, he uniquely
"distinguished himself by a series of bold, heroic actions, exemplified by
singularly outstanding combat leadership, personal bravery, and tenacious
devotion to duty, during the period from 14 June to 3 September 1944" in
at least five separate battles at Renouf, Orglandes, and St. Lô in France
as well as at Heer, Belgium, during which he was wounded many times and
for which he received seven Purple Hearts. PEOPLE Weekly reporter Michael
Ryan, in the same article of June 11, 1984 noted above, corroborates the
unusual quality of Urban's CMH-cited combat actions when he wrote that
Matt Urban's "citation is unusual in that it mentions 10 separate acts of
bravery that span practically the entire Normandy campaign." During that
Normandy campaign, the Germans against whom he fought named then Captain
Matt Louis Urban The Ghost (Der Geist in German) because no matter how
many times they thought they had killed him, he always came back to fight
them again in another place.
Let's consider his Congressional Medal of Honor citation, one that was
read publicly by President Jimmy Carter on July 19, 1980, the day when
Matt Urban received his Congressional Medal of Honor: "Lieutenant Colonel
(then Captain) Urban, 112-22-2414, United States Army, who distinguished
himself by a series of bold, heroic actions, exemplified by singularly
outstanding combat leadership, personal bravery, and tenacious devotion to
duty, during the period 14 June to 3 September 1944 while assigned to the
2d Battalion, 60th Infantry, 9th Infantry Division. On 14 June, Captain
Urban's Company, attacking at Renouf, France, encountered heavy enemy
small arms and tank fire. The enemy tanks were unmercifully raking his
unit's positions and inflicting heavy casualties. Captain Urban, realizing
that his company was in imminent danger of being decimated, armed himself
with a bazooka. He worked his way with an ammo carrier through hedgerows,
under a continuing barrage of fire, to a point near the tanks. He brazenly
exposed himself to the enemy fire and, firing his bazooka, destroyed both
tanks. Responding to Captain Urban's action, his company moved forward and
routed the enemy. Later that same day, still in the attack near Orgalndes,
Captain Urban was wounded in the leg by direct fire from a 37mm tank gun.
He refused evacuation and continued to lead his company until they moved
into defensive positions for the night. At 0500 hours the next day, still
in the attack near Orglandes, Captain Urban, though badly wounded,
directed his company in another attack. One hour later he was again
wounded. Suffering from two wounds, one serious, he was evacuated to
England. In mid-July, while recovering from his wounds, he learned of his
unit's severe losses in the hedgerows of Normandy. Realizing his unit's
need for battle-tested leaders, he voluntarily left the hospital and
hitchhiked his way back to his unit near St. Lô, France. Arriving at the
2d Battalion Command Post at 1130 hours, 25 July, he found that his unit
had jumped-off at 1100 hours in the first attack of 'Operation Cobra.'
Still limping from his leg wound, Captain Urban made his way forward to
retake command of his company. He found his company held up by strong
enemy opposition. Two supporting tanks had been destroyed and another,
intact but with no tank commander or gunner, was not moving. He located a
lieutenant in charge of the support tanks and directed a plan of attack to
eliminate the enemy strong-point. The lieutenant and a sergeant were
immediately killed by the heavy enemy fire when they tried to mount the
tank. With enemy bullets ricocheting from the tank, Captain Urban ordered
the tank forward and, completely exposed to the enemy fire, manned the
machine gun and placed devastating fire on the enemy. His action, in the
face of enemy fire, galvanized the battalion into action, and they
attacked and destroyed the enemy position. On 2 August, Captain Urban was
wounded in the chest by shell fragments and, disregarding the
recommendation of the Battalion Surgeon, again refused evacuation. On 6
August, Captain Urban became the commander of the 2d Battalion. On 15
August, he was again wounded but remained with his unit. On 3 September,
the 2d Battalion was given the mission of establishing a crossing-point on
the Meuse River near Heer, Belgium. The enemy planned to stop the advance
of the allied Army by concentrating heavy forces at the Meuse. The 2d
Battalion, attacking toward the crossing-point, encountered fierce enemy
artillery, small arms and mortar fire, which stopped the attack. Captain
Urban quickly moved from his command post to the lead position of the
battalion. Reorganizing the attacking elements, he personally led a charge
toward the enemy's strong point. As the charge moved across the open
terrain, Captain Urban was seriously wounded in the neck. Although unable
to talk above a whisper from the paralyzing neck wound, and in danger of
losing his life, he refused to be evacuated until the enemy was routed and
his battalion had secured the crossing-point on the Meuse River. Captain
Urban's personal leadership, limitless bravery, and repeated extraordinary
exposure to enemy fire served as an inspiration to his entire battalion.
His valorous and intrepid actions reflect the utmost credit on him and
uphold the noble traditions of the United States."
First in the summer of 1998, then in the winter of 1999, and recently in
the spring of 2001, American motion picture aficionados had the
opportunity to view three nostalgic, thought-provoking hit motion
pictures, Saving Private Ryan, The Thin Red Line, and Pearl Harbor, being
the fictional stories of realistic World War II combat in the European and
Pacific Theaters of (Military) Operations respectively. From now until our
task is completed, we Polish Americans should be obligated, in my opinion,
to work to perpetuate the memory of Lieutenant Colonel Matt Louis Urban
(shortened from Urbanowicz), a documented real, not fictional, American
hero for the ages, by collecting signatures on petitions urging the United
States Postal Service to issue a stamp in his honor in 2005. Friends,
forget Rambo, the fictional product of some Hollywood writer's
imagination, but teach your children and inform your friends and
associates to always remember The Ghost, Matt Louis Urban, the real
product of Polish American parents in Buffalo, NY, a high school star
athlete, a college student at Cornell University who worked several part
time jobs to pay for his tuition and living expenses, and an ROTC (Reserve
Officers Training Corps) graduate from Cornell as well.
As far as I am concerned, the matter should not be delayed beyond that
point given the fact that Matt Urban himself incredibly had to wait 35
years to receive his Congressional Medal of Honor because of the
"bureaucratic shuffle" with his records in our federal government.
Unintentional error though it was, it was an injustice to him and his
family. It robbed him of national notoriety in the years immediately
following the end of World War II when Hollywood film writers and
producers would have jumped at the rights to his story as an
"All-American" hero.
Among today's most dedicated Polish Americans, that I know of personally,
who have labored in collecting signatures as part of the "package" of
Postal Service requirements for convincing it to issue a commemorative
stamp for Urban in 2005 are John Merten of Toms River, New Jersey, and
Walter Stanko of Swansea, Massachusetts. There may be others. Perhaps the
widespread distribution of this article will awaken them to the need for
coalescing our common mission. That process indeed has already started. In
the summer of 2001, I had the honor to visit John Merten in his Toms
River, New Jersey home. It was through Francis X. Gates of Brooklyn, New
York, a fellow National Director of the Polish American Congress, from
whom I had learned earlier that Merten, the undisputed East Coast pioneer
and leader of the signature-gathering campaign, was desirous of turning
over his legendary, laboriously-collected 14,000 signatures for the Matt
Urban cause to me, citing both his age and his wife's health as factors
contributing to that decision. In accepting his 14,000-signature
collection, I promised to pursue our common Polonia mission to a
successful conclusion, one that must engage the broader attention and
support of our Polish American community nationally. Merten, on his part,
stated that "I trust you personally, that you will continue the work, and
make it happen. We have to fight for Polish people, we are proud to be
Polish, and have to be treated as everybody else, with respect. We need to
show what we do and how good we are."
On that day during which he and his wife extended their gracious
hospitality, I pleasantly learned that he had been born in Salem,
Massachusetts and that his childhood Polish surname had been Mazurczyk!
Trained to be a chemical engineer in his early adulthood, he was advised,
in a not too surprising story that I've heard paralleled from others of
his generation, to consider changing his name because the corporation in
which he sought professional employment had several German managers who
had been reluctant to hire Polish-surnamed Americans. (Editor's Note:
Henry T. Wróbel's story,
Polish Political Power, that appeared in the April/May/June 2001 issue of
The Life of Polonia, related his father's problems when he, a
valedictorian graduate of Worcester Polytechnic Institute with a
bachelor's degree in electrical engineering, faced similar obstacles when
he began seeking employment in Massachusetts.)
In the fall of 2001, I also traveled to the home of another "legend" in
the leadership ranks of the Matt Urban signature-gathering cause. Walter
Stanko of Swansea, Massachusetts, a WWII veteran of the 9th Infantry
Division who had been collecting some 400 to 500 signatures per month for
several years, most of which he had been sending to John Merten, but in
the last year or so, began sending to me. As the result of the superlative
hard work of John Merten and Walter Stanko, I now have the collection of
some 17,000 to 18,000 signatures. Though those signatures represent a
solid foundation, they alone, in their present quantity, will not suffice
for purposes of convincing the Postal Service to issue the commemorative
stamp. Those signatures are, in effect, round one of the campaign. If in
subsequent rounds, the United States Postal Service proves reluctant to
issue a commemorative stamp, then the matter may have to be resolved in
the political arena of the United States Congress.
Today, through this modified version of the original story under the same
title that appeared in the October – December 2001 issue of The Life of
Polonia, the quarterly publication of the Polish American Congress of
Eastern Massachusetts, I am appealing to my fellow Polish Americans and
other Americans of good will who believe in fair play, justice, and honor
in the matter of issuing a commemorative stamp in memory of Matt Louis
Urban, to collect signatures. Just simple signatures. If Walter Stanko
alone had been able to collect 400 to 500 signatures a month in the
Narragansett Bay area of southern Massachusetts, entire states with large
Polish American populations should have no trouble in collecting 1,000 or
more signatures!
My fellow Americans, we owe it to the memory of Matt Louis Urban
(1919-1995) – a distinguished American highest decorated combat veteran of
World War II, distinguished disabled American veteran, recipient of seven
Purple Hearts, recipient of the Congressional Medal of Honor,
distinguished veteran of foreign wars, distinguished ROTC graduate of
Cornell University, Class of 1941, courageous and inspirational combat
leader, loving son, brother, husband, and father, distinguished Polish
American, and wholesome role model as a hero for the ages in the history
of the United States.
So now let's just do it! Let's bring this mission for a real, rather than
fictitious, American hero of World War II to a successful conclusion by
convincing the United States Postal Service to issue a commemorative stamp
in his honor soon. This is our mission.
Copies of the petition can be accessed and downloaded readily from the
website of the Polish American Congress of Eastern Massachusetts
(www.paceasternmass.org) Once in the website, click on Links for access to
a 1946 photograph of Matt Urban as well as for the text of his
Congressional Medal of Honor citation, and the petition for collecting
signatures.
Note: The author is National Vice President for American Affairs, Polish
American Congress, Chicago, IL and Washington, DC; President of the Polish
American Congress of Eastern Massachusetts, Inc., Boston, MA; President
and Founder of the American Association of the Friends of Kościuszko at
West Point, Inc., Boston, MA; and Associate Dean (Ret.) and Senior
Lecturer in History, Northeastern University, Boston, MA. In November 1999
the Council of National Directors of the Polish American Congress
appointed him its National Executive Chairman of the Lt. Col. Matt Louis
Urban Commemorative Stamp Committee.
|